Showing posts with label BIS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label BIS. Show all posts

Friday, August 15, 2025

Upcoming changes in NBC 2016 Part 4 ANNEX J (Clause 6.4.4) J-8 & J-9

Upcoming changes in NBC 2016 Part 4 ANNEX J (Clause 6.4.4) J-8 & J-9 

As on date 15-08-2025, latest version of NBC 2025 still not released. This post is tentative only. Latest version of NBC 2025 is applicable for existing buildings when they are altered (see clause 12.4 of Part 2) or in the opinion of the authority constitute a hazard to the safety of the adjacent property or to the occupants of the building itself or are unsafe.

Annex J for FIRE AND LIFE SAFETY REQUIREMENTS FOR METRO STATIONS.

J-1 APPLICATION AND SCOPE

J-2 TERMINOLOGY

J-3 GENERAL

J-4 LIFE SAFETY REQUIREMENTS

J-5 EGRESS PROVISIONS

J-6 FIRE SEPARATION AND COMPARTMENTATION

J-7 OTHER SPECIFICS REGARDING SAFETY REQUIREMENTS

New upcoming J-8 POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM

New upcoming J-9 EMERGENCY LIGHTING SYSTEM

J-8 POWER SUPPLY SYSTEM

In NBC 2016 Part 4 says “the back-up/emergency power supply shall have a capacity to cater all critical loads such as emergency lighting, protective signalling system, communication system, fire station and control room, lifts providing required egress capacity, etc.”

Now upcoming NBC 2025 Part 4 under Annex J-8 says.

J-8.1 General

The Auxiliary Substation at Metro stations can be provided at any location, for example, Ground Level, Concourse Level, Platform Level, etc. The access for dismantling and replacement in future and ease of operation and maintenance of the equipment are to be ensured.

J-8.2 Uninterrupted Power Supply (UPS) System

The UPS shall be an online parallel redundant system with battery back-up for emergency power supply. The batteries shall provide backup for minimum 90 minutes.

If, DG set power backup to UPS is provided, the battery backup time shall be suitably selected.

J-8.3 Back-up or Emergency Power supply

a) The back-up/emergency power supply shall have a capacity to cater all critical loads such as emergency lighting, protective signaling system, communication system, station control room/fire command centre, lifts providing required egress capacity, etc.

b) Power supply to these systems and equipment shall be from normal and emergency (standby generator power sources with changeover facility).

c) If the power supply is taken from HT source and HT generation, the transformer shall be selected with standby capacity to ensure continuity of power supply to such systems. Where parallel HV/LV supply from a separate independent source is provided with appropriate transformer for emergency, the provision of Diesel Generator for emergency supply may be waived at the discretion of Metro Authority. In such a scenario, in case of failure of Mains power, the transfer to emergency power supply should be automatic and within 10 s for ensuring uninterrupted supply to emergency systems.

J-8.4 Cables

a) Fire resistant/survival, low smoke zero halogen, copper conductor, armoured, XLPE insulated cables shall be used at enclosed stations for fire and life safety equipment like Fire Alarm System (FAS), Tunnel Ventilation Fans, Smoke Extraction Fans, Staircase Pressurization Fans, fire pumps, emergency lighting, etc.

b) All cables and wiring used for fire and life safety equipment shall have a 3h fire survival capability at 950 °C.

c) For all other essential services at enclosed stations like Chillers, AHU, Normal lighting, Chilled Water pumps etc. flame retardant, low smoke zero-halogen (LSZH), armoured, XLPE insulated Aluminium/copper conductor cables shall be used.

d) At open stations, flame retardant, low smoke halogen free (FR, LSH), armoured, XLPE insulated Aluminium/copper conductor cables shall be used for power supply.

e) Fire alarm system signalling loop circuit (SLC) cable must be in red colour. Other hand Power cable must be in black colour.

J-9 EMERGENCY LIGHTING SYSTEM

a) LED lighting fixtures shall be used for lighting at Metro stations.

b) Emergency illumination shall include illumination of means of egress, illuminated exit signs, and all other luminaires specified as necessary to provide required illumination. Emergency lighting systems shall be designed and installed so that the failure of any illumination source cannot leave in total darkness any space that requires emergency illumination. Emergency lighting shall not provide less than average of 10 lux. Minimum illumination of 10 lux shall be maintained on egress route.

c) Fire resistant (FR), low smoke and zero halogen (LSZH) copper conductor wires shall be used for wiring of emergency lighting system at underground stations.

Emergency lighting system (ELS) circuit shall have 3hr fire survival (FS) capability at 950°C.

d) Out of total light fixtures installed at any station, at least 30% of the total lights, all uniformly distributed shall be connected to emergency power source,  that is, UPS.

e) Emergency lighting shall be powered from a source independent of  that supplying  the normal lighting.


REFERENCE:

CED 46(26992) WC - Draft Code for Comments Only.







Sunday, June 15, 2025

Fire Rated Door & What Should Keep In Mind

Does Your Building Need Fire Rated Door & What Should Keep In Mind? 

When a fire emergency strikes, nothing is more important than ensuring the safety of the people inside the premises. And while many factors to consider—like having adequately trained security guards and reliable fire alarms—one of the most effective tools are fireproof doors.

Ensuring the safety and fire resistance of buildings is paramount, particularly in areas that are critical for containment and evacuation during emergencies. The National Building Code (NBC) outlines specific requirements for the installation of fire door assemblies to enhance fire protection across various building components and areas. This summary categorises these requirements into general building components, specific shafts and chutes, lobbies, stairwells, basements, corridors, egress pathways, high hazard areas, and special situations. By adhering to these guidelines, the integrity of fire containment within structures is significantly improved, providing safer environments for occupants and aiding in effective emergency response efforts. The following sections detail the specific fire door ratings required for each critical area as per NBC clauses.

WHAT IS A FIRE-RATED DOOR?

Let’s be realistic: doors cannot be 100% fireproof. When fires break out inside a property, they create an intense heat known to melt steel doors. However, the function of fire-rated doors isn’t to survive the flames; instead, it’s to slow down the blaze and limit any potential damage from spreading throughout the entire building.

A fire-rated door is a type of door that is specifically designed to resist the effects of fire. They are typically rated by how long they can withstand the heat and flames without sustaining damage. It usually takes into account the material the door is made of, its thickness, shape, and size. The higher the rating, the longer it will be able to withstand fire before it sustains damage or becomes unusable.

Some doors are designed to keep out smoke and heat for 30 minutes, while others can withstand longer. These doors seal the area tightly and protect it from intense heat and smoke regardless of the type.

DO YOU NEED ONE IN YOUR BUILDING?

Modern buildings often require fire-rated doors to abide by the National Building Code of India 2016 is mandates. These doors surround staircase and elevator shafts to help keep smoke or fire from spreading through numerous building floors.

High-Rise Buildings: These doors are often used in high-rise buildings where fire safety is crucial due to the potential for rapid fire spread and evacuation challenges.

Commercial Buildings: Insulated fire doors are commonly installed in commercial structures such as office buildings, shopping malls, and hotels to compartmentalise fire and prevent its spread, protecting occupants and property.

Industrial Facilities: Industries with high fire risk, such as manufacturing plants and warehouses storing flammable materials, may utilise insulated fire doors to contain fires within specific areas and prevent them from spreading throughout the facility.

Healthcare Facilities: Hospitals and medical centers employ insulated fire doors to safeguard patients, staff, and sensitive equipment from fire hazards, maintaining critical operations during emergencies.

If your building does not currently have a fire-rated door, it is recommended to consult an experienced contractor like SSA Integrate to install one for you.

THE ANATOMY OF A FIRE DOOR

A fire door consists of many different components, such as frames, doors, hardware, seals and glass that help keep out flames or smoke once closed.

Thermal insulation in fire door assemblies is most important under anatomy of a fire door.

FIRE RATING LABEL

On fire ratings, you may see several minutes or hours. It is the fire endurance rating, which the certifying agency gives after exposing the door to extreme temperatures reaching as high as 1,925° F (approximately 1,000° C). You’ll see these in intervals of 30, 60, 120, or 240 minutes, while some labels show hours. Fire rating labels are typically found on the hinge side of the door and the door frame, hidden from view.

Insulated fire doors are tested for both integrity and insulation, further divided into partially insulated (minimum 60 minutes insulation) and fully insulated (integrity rating equals insulation rating). Uninsulated fire doors are tested solely for integrity. As per NBC the ratings are:

A. GENERAL BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION TYPES

1. Type 1 to 3 Construction

• Clause 3.4.5: Every wall opening protected with fire-resisting doors (120 min rating).

2. Type 4 Construction

• Clause 3.4.5.3: Openings in fire separating walls or floors fitted with fire-resistant assemblies (120 min rating). 

B. CORRIDORS AND EGRESS PATHWAYS

1. Exit Access Corridors in Specific Occupancies

• Clause 4.6.1: Fire doors (20 min self-closing for corridors, 120 min for exit passageways).

2. Progressive Horizontal Evacuation Compartments

• Clause 6.3.2 (c): Self-closing fire doors with electromagnetic hold open and sequence coordinators.

• Clause 6.3.2 (g) (12): Fire doors (120 min rating).

C. HIGH HAZARD AREAS

1. Pump House

• Clause 5.1.2.2 (c): Fire doors (120 min rating).

2. Stores, Engineering Workshops, High Hazard Areas

• Clause 6.1.2 (d): Fire doors with signage to be kept closed.

• Clause 6.7.1.1 (m): Two fire doors (180 min rating each).

D. SPECIFIC BUILDING COMPONENTS AND AREAS

1. Firefighting Shaft (Fire Tower)

• Clause 2.24: Fire doors (120 min rating).

2. Horizontal Exit

• Clause 2.39: Fire doors in fire-resistant walls (120 min rating).

3. Fire Command Centre (FCC)

• Clause 3.4.12 (b): Fire doors (120 min rating).

4. Electrical and Plumbing Shafts

• Clause 3.4.5.4: Electrical service ducts and shafts (120 min rating).

• Clause 3.4.5.4*: Plumbing shafts with doors opening inside the building (30 min rating).

5. Refuse Chutes

• Clause 3.4.5.5: Inspection panel and doors (60 min rating).

6. Lift Lobby and Stairwell

• Clause 4.2.7: Fire doors (120 min rating).

7. Basement Car Parking

• Clause 4.2.19 (c): Door openings to basement (120 min rating).

8. Access to Exit Staircase

• Clause 4.4.2.4.3.2 (h) (2): Fire doors (120 min rating).

9. Lift Lobby

• Table 6 (Note 1): Fire doors (120 min rating).

These groupings facilitate a clearer understanding of where fire door assemblies are needed according to their specific applications and requirements.

fire door specification as per NBC

In the building safety, fire door specification as per NBC play a crucial role in protecting lives and property.

The National Building Code (NBC) of India is a comprehensive set of guidelines that ensure the safety, health, and sustainability of buildings. When it comes to fire doors, the NBC outlines specific requirements to enhance fire safety. Here’s a closer look at the key specifications:

1.   Fire Resistance Rating NBC mandates that fire doors must have a minimum fire resistance rating, usually measured in hours. The rating indicates how long the door can withstand fire exposure while maintaining its integrity. Common ratings are 30, 60, 90, and 120 minutes.

2.   Material and Construction Fire doors must be constructed from materials that can withstand high temperatures and prevent the spread of fire and smoke. Steel and timber are common materials used, often with a core of fire-resistant material.

3.   Door Frame and Hardware The door frame, hinges, locks, and other hardware components must also meet fire resistance standards. Self-closing mechanisms are essential to ensure the door closes automatically in the event of a fire.

4.   Smoke Seals Effective smoke seals are crucial in fire doors to prevent the spread of smoke, which can be as dangerous as the fire itself. The NBC specifies the type and installation of these seals.

5.   Glazing If a fire door includes glazed panels, the glass must be fire-rated and comply with NBC guidelines. The glazing should maintain its integrity under fire conditions for a specified period.

6.   Installation Proper installation is as important as the door itself. NBC specifies that fire doors must be installed by trained professionals to ensure they function correctly in an emergency.

Benefits of NBC Compliant Fire Doors

Adhering to NBC specifications for fire doors offers numerous benefits:

·        Enhanced Safety: Ensures maximum protection for occupants by containing fire and smoke.

·        Legal Compliance: Meets regulatory requirements, reducing liability and ensuring legal adherence.

·        Peace of Mind: Provides reassurance that your building is equipped with the best fire safety measures. 

FIRE RESISTANT DOOR

Fire-rated doors themselves can be either made from wood or steel. Steel fire-rated doors typically have higher fire ratings because they are non-flammable and don’t contribute to the flame – no matter what situation arises. Wooden fire-rated doors are usually equipped with a gypsum core, which is resistant to heat and not combustible, or they may contain a regular plasterboard instead.

FIRE RESISTANT GLASS AND SEALS

Some fire doors may include vision panels with glass rated for fires, but these are typically only seen in lower fire-rated doors. Fire doors must also have an intumescent strip at the bottom to seal them off from outside air sources. 

The glass used in fire door assemblies is tested for its ability to withstand intense heat. However, current codes also require it to be tested for resistance against being shattered. It means that each piece of glass must have markings labelled as either resistant against impact or hazardous when broken due to heat exposure. Otherwise, the glass can not be used indoors or in other areas where people risk damaging them.

FIRE RESISTANT LATCHING HARDWARE

Fire-rated doors must be shut close during fires, or the door won’t stop or slow the spread of fire and smoke. Every fire door needs self-closing mechanisms combined with steel ball-bearing hinges, as these are tougher than standard ones.

FIRE PROTECTIVE VS FIRE RESISTIVE DOORS 

Knowing the difference between fire-resistant and fire-protective matters because you need to consider how much protection your property needs. It can depend on your commercial building; for example, you need a fire-resistive door in a school science lab with highly combustible substances that require protection from high heat.

Fire Protective: If an assembly is classified as fire-protective, it defends against the spread of flames and smoke to protect people for a specific time. A typical fire-protective door would be appropriate if building codes allow door-protective assemblies, including the door itself, sidelights, or windows. Traditional wired glass, glass ceramics, and tempered glass can all be used to achieve this protection. 

This type only partially stops heat from transferring to the other side of the glass, but it can be fire-rated for up to 180 minutes but with size limitations. 

Fire Resistive: If an assembly is fire-resistant, it has the same protection against flames and smoke as its fire-protective counterpart but also offers another level of security by blocking off radiant and conductive heat. 

Fire resistance is weaker than fireproofing. Most fire-resistant doors are only rated for 45 minutes’ worth of protection against fires or smoke. Experts point out that the chief difference between fire-resistant and fireproofing materials is that they are not supposed to be able to contain heat.

CAN GLASS DOORS BE FIRE-RATED?

Fire-rated glass is a particular type of glass that is specifically designed to offer protection against fires. It acts as an impenetrable shield against flames, thus preventing them from spreading, and it stops any smoke from invading other parts of the building. 

Depending on the type of glass used, this glazed panel may also act as an insulator, which protects the rest of the building from extreme heat caused by fires. All fire-rated doors containing glass must use fire-resistant material, according to strict building regulations.

Manufacturers offer a wide range of fire-resistant glass doors for various applications. For instance, these doors are used in high-rise buildings and other places requiring higher security levels. The door, frame, lite kits, and hardware create the necessary protection for the building.

Installing a fire-rated door is not easy, but it can be done with the help of experts in the industry. Hart Engineering prides itself on creating compliant solutions that provide customers with peace of mind regarding fire safety. Contact SSA Integrate today, and we’ll help ensure that your property has the necessary equipment to meet your needs.

Before choosing fire-rated glass for your project, consider these factors: 

·        NBC Part 4 Certification – Ensure the glass meets NBC Part 4 fire safety standards, which outline essential fire protection measures. 

·        BIS Standards Compliance – Fire-rated glass should be tested under IS 16947:2018 and IS 16945:2018, India’s benchmark standards for fire resistance and safety. 

·        Local Fire Department Approvals – Each state or city has its own fire safety regulations. Ensure that your fire-rated glass is pre-approved for municipal construction projects. 

·        Third-Party Certifications – Look for additional certifications, such as IGBC, GRIHA, or LEED, which indicate compliance with sustainable and safety standards.

NBC sets clear performance standards based on three classifications: 

E-Class (Integrity Only) – The First Line of Defense

This type of fire-rated glass prevents the spread of flames and smoke but does not block heat transfer. It’s ideal for applications where containing fire is crucial, but radiant heat protection isn’t a major concern. 

EW-Class (Integrity + Radiation Control) – Extra Protection

EW-Class glass takes it a step further by reducing the amount of heat transferred through the glass. This means that while it prevents flames and smoke from spreading, it also minimises the impact of radiant heat, making it safer for evacuation routes. 

EI-Class (Integrity + Insulation) – Maximum Safety  

This is the gold standard of fire-rated glass. Not only does it stop flames and smoke, but it also blocks radiant heat. This is ideal for high-risk areas where occupant safety is a priority. 

When selecting fire-rated glass, it’s essential to choose the right classification based on the building’s function and fire safety needs.

NBC has mapped out specific areas that require fire-rated glass to ensure maximum safety while maintaining architectural integrity.

By strategically integrating fire-rated glass in these key areas, buildings can meet NBC compliance while enhancing safety without sacrificing aesthetics. 

Here’s where it should be used: 

Internal & External Fire Exit Stairways – These are critical evacuation routes. Fire-rated doors and partitions help contain the fire and provide a safe exit path. 

Firefighting Shafts – Essential for emergency responders, these areas must be enclosed with fire-resistant materials to keep them operational during a fire. 

Non-Naturally Ventilated Lift Lobbies – Since smoke buildup in lift areas can be dangerous, fire-rated glass barriers help create a smoke-free zone. 

Refuge Areas – Designated safe zones in high-rise buildings need fire-rated partitions to provide temporary protection while evacuation is underway. 

Car Parking Separations – Parking garages carry a fire risk due to fuel exposure and vehicle congestion. Fire-resistant walls help contain potential fires, preventing them from spreading and enhancing overall safety. 

Kitchen Separations – Commercial and residential kitchens require heat-resistant barriers to prevent fire from spreading to other areas.

Who Can Inspect Fire Doors?
Fire doors play a critical role in protecting life and property — but only if they’re working as intended. That’s why annual inspections are required.
But here’s the question:

Who’s qualified to perform them?
According to NFPA 80, inspections must be performed by a qualified person — someone with the knowledge of door operation and applicable codes.
 
That person could be:
 • A third-party fire door inspector
 • A trained building employee (Training Certificate must show)

 •  A person who attend “Capsule Course on NBC 2016” from NITS, BIS (Attendance Certificate must show)

 • Even the property owner if certified.

So who decides what “qualified” means?
 
👉 The Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) does.

Qualification is typically based on demonstrated knowledge through a recognized degree, certification, professional standing (Like NFPA Member), or training.


About Author:

Dr. Arindam Bhadra is a Fire safety consultant based in Kolkata, India, with over 20 years of experience in Fire safety systems. He’s currently founding director of the Sprinkler Fire Safety Awareness and Welfare Foundation & SSA Integrate. He working on Fire Safety awareness, training, consultancy & Audit in same field. Dr. Arindam Bhadra is popularly known as "Fire ka Doctor" because of his expertise in fire safety, prevention, and awareness, helping people and organizations stay safe from fire hazards. He is Member of FSAI, NFPA etc. He is certified fire Inspector and certified Fire Protection professional.

Tuesday, April 1, 2025

Open Protocol & Closed Protocol under Fire Alarms

Open Protocol & Closed Protocol under Fire Alarms 

Thanks to all of my viewr to promote me and thanks for nice name is given to me as "Fire Ka Doctor". Below Article is quite different then others. In fire industry verious miscommunication / mishandling / wrong concept is going on. This open protocol & Close protocol is one of them. Yes after reading this article set your mindset and ask your perchaser. Dont beleave blindly any OEM or nominated persons. 

We are often asked about “Open Protocol” or “Open Architecture” systems or “Closed Protocol” or “proprietary”. Although this is quite a technical question, it is one of the fundamental issues to be addressed when specifying a fire detection and alarm system. Fire alarm industry creates a misunderstanding of what an Open Protocol System or Closed. 

·        Some of OEM said we have Over 1000 of Distribution globally and we believe Open protocol business strategy.

·        Another OEM said our Fire alarm product is Open Protocol, it is unlocked, and any third-party company is then available to maintain the system.

·        We are believing one of best open protocol product we supply globally that any one can do programming commissioning from our panel Keypad. All manuals are easily available in online search engines. No need training no software not mandatory.

·        We have Open Protocol Interfaces such as BACNet, Modbus and OPC Server, that can be easily handshake with any Third Party system.

Lots of OEM is there globally, each and every one is correct in terms of their “strategy – thinking”. These terms primarily relate to fire alarm systems' communication and compatibility aspects.

All fire detection and alarm systems are technically similar. In very simple terms, they consist of numerous fire detection devices, including smoke detectors and “break glass” call points for example, which are connected to a central control panel. When a smoke detector detects smoke, it informs the control panel, which then turns on circuits of alarm sounders. Smoke detector operates, alarm sounders ring. (if you want to be really simple about it!). The connection between the detection devices, alarm sounders and the control panel is either cabling or wireless. For simplicity, we will focus on systems where the devices are connected to the control panel by cabling, commonly called in the industry a “hard wired” system.

What is a Protocol?

Each component uses a particular protocol, which is essentially the language that electronic products use to communicate with each other. So a protocol is a fire alarm system's language for communicating between loop devices. 

There are two types of protocol for fire systems: open or closed.

BS EN 54-13-2017 stated

“The components forming a FDAS are designed to provide a system with a particular aspect of its overall functionality. Only when all the components are connected together is the system likely to perform in the desired manner and then only if the components intercommunicate effectively.

For the purposes of this document, the CIE is the focal point of the system and all other components are required to communicate effectively with the CIE. Communication requires the consideration of communication protocols along with other aspects such as power supply requirements and data transmission characteristics.

A separate voice alarm system can be assessed for compatibility and connectability independently of the fire detection and alarm system.”

In general you can say Open Protocol fire alarm is Conventional type & Close protocol Fire Alarm is Addressable type or Intelligent type.

Open Protocol Fire Alarm System

In an Open Protocol System, the panel and devices manufactured by different companies – as long as they are compatible. Open Protocol System designed to be more flexible and open to communication with a wider range of devices and components. This flexibility can make it easier to expand, upgrade, and maintain the fire alarm system, as components from various manufacturers can be integrated into the system more easily. Open protocol systems often offer more choices and competitive pricing for replacement parts and devices.

A conventional system employs one or more initiating circuits called zone’s, connected to sensors (initiating devices) wired in parallel. These sensors are devised to decrease the circuits resistance when the environmental influence on any sensor exceeds a predetermined threshold. No programming needs to be done, just plug & Play. The conventional fire panel range comes in 2, 4 or 8 zones or more versions.

NFPA 72 Standard says

1) Each zone has a maximum area of 2000 square meters.

2) The maximum length of each zone is 3000 meters.

3) The maximum number of elements in each zone (including fire alarms, sirens, mcp, detectors, etc.) is 24, and it is better to have a maximum of 20 elements.

4) Each residential floor can be placed in one zone.

5) It is suggested that each escape staircase should be included in a zone and a fire alarm should be installed on the escape route.

6) False ceilings and ceilings with a height of more than 80 cm need a detector.

7) If the partition distance is less than 30 cm, the detector is considered separate.

8) If the height of the ceiling is more than 50 cm, a separate detector is considered for each space.

9) The maximum coverage area for the smoke detector is 100 square meters and for the heat detector is 60 square meters.

10) The maximum height of the detector is 12 meters for the detector and 8 meters for the thermal detector.

The Gent 3260 is a conventional fire alarm system support up to 32 devices per zone.

Ravel Conventional panel can support 28nos elements/detectors in each zone if Ravel brand conventional elements, It supports 20 or 18nos if other then Ravel conventional elements. It depends on Current consumption. Yes it supports other brand elements.

GST conventional Fire panel each zone can be connected with 15 conventional fire detectors in same brand or other brand conventional detectors.

Agni Protection conventional fire panel support Maximum 20 nos. detectors in each zone. If other brand detectors, then also same.

AGNI Devices conventional fire panel support Maximum 25 nos. detectors in each zone. If other brand detectors, then also same.

EATON conventional fire panel support maximum loading is 32 detectors and manual call points per zone,

System Sensor Fire Alarm Control Panel support maximum 600m cable connectivity per zone, typically 20 Detectors per zone+ 5 MCP's. Other brand Detector can be connected with respect to Max 2mA current per Detector Circuit.

Apollo conventional ranges including Series 65, Orbis and Series 65A support any brand Conventional Fire Panel. Any series cover 10-year warranty policy. Apollo Fire Detectors Limited is a Halma Company.

In case of Addressable or Intelligent system, only apollo brand field elements (including modules, Strobe, MCP, detectors, etc. Apollo is manufactures smoke detectors, call points, VADs, and more recently, pull stations and magnetic door holders.) are compatible with

1.   Mtech Fire Detection Systems Ltd

2.   Labor Strauss Sicherungsanlagenbau GmbH (LST)

3.   NIBBLE - Engenharia Lda

4.   Ampac Europe Limited

5.   Safetec SRL

6.   Paradox Hellas (SmartX)

7.   Haes Technologies Ltd (Esprit)

8.   Kentec Electronics Ltd (Syncro, Taktis)

9.   NSC Sicherheitstechnik GmbH

10.Teledata SRL

11.VES LLC

12.C-TEC  (Apollo & Hochiki)

13.Advanced Electronics Ltd (MxPro)

So there are two different OEM involve in Fire Detection & Alarm system. You can Design for small to Enterprise customers, in any sector. Apollo products are certified in a global arena to meet the highest standards set by both our customers and the dynamic and challenging environments in which they operate. We meet global type approval standards including EN, UL, CCC as well as specific approvals for specialist or extreme applications such as Marine or explosive environments. The compliance to these standards can be denoted by a third-party marking on the product including LPCB, VdS, BOSEC and AFNOR.

You able to add any of above brand Fire Panel for your design, free to select as per your customers / end users need. Apollo is single brand who offer open protocol field element compatible with lots of Fire alarm control Panel.

Advantages of Open Protocol

·        Offers the building owner more freedom when it comes to sourcing products or an installation company as there is the ability to choose between numerous compatible manufacturers.

·        Allows the installer to choose whichever products are suitable for the project.

·        The building owner is able to choose whichever company they want for ongoing maintenance or adding to the system, enabling them to shop around for the best price

·        When innovative products are released, and the building owner would prefer this solution to protect their building (like our flush mounted Soteria Dimension) having an open protocol system makes it easier to change manufacturer. Meaning they have more flexibility to choose the solution they want, not the ones they are tied into.

·        open protocol systems can sometimes offer more competitive pricing and long-term cost savings.

·        Different manufacturers for panels & devices – when things do go wrong, more than one company may have to be involved to find a solution, software, etc.

Disadvantages of Open Protocol:

·        No training required, so no proof of competence. Installer, Customers need to find out actual competent person who can make healthy system.

·        Easy access to software can lead to untrained engineers working on systems. No license / Dongle is required.

·        open protocol systems offer flexibility but may require careful selection and integration of components to ensure seamless operation.

Closed Protocol Fire Alarm System

With a Closed Protocol system a single manufacturer produces a range of devices AND control panels that all utilise its own specific protocol. This manufacturer does not provide general access to the technical details of its protocol and restricts the use of it to trained approved installation companies only. The equipment produced will not be compatible with devices from different manufacturers of closed protocol fire systems. Once you choose one closed protocol you are, in effect, locked into one company for the manufacture, supply and maintenance (and in some instances the installation) of the complete system. which can lead to higher costs and potential limitations in system flexibility.

Conventional system with close protocol is not possible, due to conventional system is plug & play. On the other hand analog addressable or intelligent addressable system is with close protocol.

Close Protocol Communicate with Same Brand Field Element & Fire Panel Only

Fire Brand Name

Main Company

Protocol Name

Compatible Panel

 

Remarks

Notifier

Honeywell

Flashscan
Clip

NFS 320
NFS2 640E
NFS2 3030
N16e

UL & FM

Detector, Devices can be program through auto program Panel
Integrated Digital Voice program via license Software (VeriFire tools) only.
License software open for Distributor Trained Person Only.

ESSER

Honeywell

Profi BUS
EDP

ESSER 8xxx
IQ8
FlexES

EN54, Vds, BOSEC, Ex, CCC, CNBOP, AFNOR & DIBt

Programming through Tools8000 software only.
License software open for Distributor Trained Person Only.

Farenhyt

Honeywell

IDP

IFP-2100ECS (RED)
IFP-2100
IFP-300
IFP-75

UL

Auto Programming through Fire Panel.
License software HFSS is open for Distributor Trained Person Only.
System is partly open with Apollo & Hochiki Field element.

Silent Knight & Farenhyt

Honeywell

IDP

IFP-2000
IFP-1000
IFP-100
IFP-50

UL

Auto Programming through Fire Panel.
License software HFSS is open for Distributor Trained Person Only.
System is partly open with Apollo & Hochiki Field element.

Silent Knigh

Honeywell

IDP

6820 EVS
6700
6808
6820

UL & FM

Auto Programming through Fire Panel.
License software SKSS2 & and the SKST selection tool is open for Distributor Trained Person Only.
6700 Honeywell will provide product support until October 2029

FireLite

Honeywell

CLIP

ES-1000XC
ES-200X
ES-1000X
ES-50XP
ES-50X
ES-200XP

UL

Auto Programming through Fire Panel.
Panel programming via a USB drive

Gamewell-FCI

Honeywell

Velocity protocol

GWF-7075
SLP-S3

UL & OSHPD (CA)

Auto Programming through Fire Panel.
Panel programming via license CamWorks software open for Distributor trained person only

GENT

Honeywell

 

COMPACT-PLUS
VIGPLUS-24
VIGPLUS-72
NANO-24

EN54

Commision Tool Gent, VigInSite Tool, Loop Diagnostic Tool & NanoTool are license-based software is open for Distributor Trained Person Only.

MORLEY IAS

Honeywell

CLIP

DxC
ZXSe
PL 1000
LT-159

MA-2000

MA-8000

EN54 & LPCB

Auto Programming through Fire Panel.
Panel programming via software open for trained person only

Simplex

JCI

IDNet or MAPNET II

4100ES
4007ES
4010ES

UL

License Based ES Programmer Software is for programming, only for distributor trained person.

FireClass

JCI

 

FC 700
FC 600
FC 500

 

Hand-held programmer is required for Detector / Devices Programming.
Panel programming via software open for trained person only

ZETTLER

JCI

 

PROFILE

UL

Hand-held programmer is required for Detector / Devices Programming.
Panel programming via software open for trained person only

PROTEC

PROTEC

Algo-Te 6000PLUS

6100
6500
VIGPLUS-72
NANO-24

EN54

Protec X600 for panels / Commisioning tool for protec 6100 Full licensed software availlable with distributor trained person only.

EATON / COOPER

EATON

 

CF1000
CF1200
CF3000

EN54 & Vds

Auto Programming through Fire Panel.
License software Site Installer is open for Trained Person Only

EDWARDS

Carrier

SIGA

iO 64
iO 1000
EST3
EST3X
EST4

UL & FM

Programming through License software (IO-CU, 3-SDU, 4-CU) only.
License software open for End User, Distributor, System Integrator Trained Person Only.

GST

Carrier

 

GST100
GST200N
IFP8
IFP4E

EN54 & LPCB

Hand-held programmer is required for Detector / Devices Programming.
Panel programming via software is open download.

Kidde

Carrier

 

VM series
VS Series

 

VMS CU License is required for Detector / Devices Programming.
Panel programming via software is open for trained Person Only

BOSCH

BOSCH

LSN

FPA 1000
FPA 2000
FPA 8000

EN54 & Vds

Programming through License software (FSP 5000 RPS) only.
License software open for Distributor, System Integrator Trained Person Only.

Advantages of Closed Protocol

·        Because each and every device in the system, including the control panel, is provided by the one manufacturer there is a common design and production plan, meaning compatibility is assured.

·        When individual devices do need upgrading they are tested alongside the rest of the manufacturer’s product range to ensure the system’s compatibility before the new products are brought to market.

·        System failure due to unauthorised tampering is reduced as access to the system is restricted by the manufacturer to approved installation and maintenance companies.

Disadvantages of Closed Protocol:

·        Upgrades to the system could be restricted to the technology currently available from the chosen manufacturer/supplier, potentially affecting your choice of brand new or innovative solutions available elsewhere in the marketplace.

·        Closed protocol manufacturers can lack competition for maintenance services and this can encourage lapse service, slow call-out responses and expensive maintenance contracts which are impossible to get out of

·        As a building owner you are wholly dependent on one manufacturer for access to new equipment, upgrades, spares and maintenance. Without direct competition this tends to allow manufacturers to charge you a premium rate for these services.

·        If you do decide to upgrade or change the system, it can be an expensive and disruptive exercise as the majority of the original supplier’s system would have to be removed from the premises and replaced. In some circumstances, this might involve multiple risk assessments and a complicated series of temporary closures of the building to the public and staff for the duration of some of the work (to comply with local legislation).

·        There is a complete dependency on one manufacturer for spare parts, and access to the protocol for servicing, modification, and upgrades. All of this may put a premium on ongoing maintenance.

·        Some of well-known OEM directly stated to End user that, do purchased from only our authorised distributor and commissioning through them only, otherwise we not able to provide warranty support. Some of them told if you commissioned system through another agency then you will not get any warranty support in case any product not in working condition.

Making the right choice

The question you need to ask yourself and your installer at this point is “What is the best investment option for me and my building, considering the whole lifetime of the fire detection system”. This “whole lifetime” investment is sometimes referred to as the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) and is an important long-term consideration.

If you decide to choose a fire detection system provided by a Closed Protocol manufacturer you will have access to devices and panels specifically designed to operate together with complete compatibility. This solution will then be installed and maintained by an approved supplier who has been trained in that specific system.

You need to be aware of some potential issues here, for example

·        Does the manufacturer have a strict upgrade policy restricting you to one upgrade per year or 5 year.

·        Do they guarantee complete backwards compatibility for their new products or will you be forced to replace some other components that don’t quite fit with the new devices? Without upgrading Firmware Versions. Some of Well known OEM discontinued old detector series and immediate effect new detector series, not End user mandatory to upgrade firmware on chargeable basis, otherwise new detector & old detector can not work jointly under loops.

·        Are there other solutions on the market that despite being more cost-effective cannot be utilised as they are not part of the manufacturer’s system offering?

·        Check there product commissioning process, does need license / dongle for every addition or deletion or modification. If yes then how many certified or non-certified technical person there in market ?

·        Do the market survey – take suggestion from experienced field person.

Potentially you might be tied-in to a lengthy maintenance contract so consider whether the manufacturer has a good reputation within the industry for the provision of equipment and services.

Opting to choose an Open Protocol system allows you and your installation company the freedom to make decisions about the precise equipment needed based upon the exact requirements of the building rather than being restricted to one manufacturer’s product range. Make sure your chosen installation company has the experience and expertise in many different manufacturer’s product ranges so that you can be sure they will offer accurate and impartial advice on the system design. It is also recommended that you check their fire industry accreditations such as BAFE or LPS1014.

Choosing the correct fire detection protocol system is dependent upon circumstance. Open protocols offer a greater degree of freedom, choice and long term value for money; however if cost is not a primary concern you may prefer the closed protocol system which can offer a straightforward alternative.

Open Protocol Systems - An Explanation. Generally Open Protocol systems allow fire detection equipment and control panels to be compatible between a greater selection of manufacturers, offering you more freedom of choice when sourcing products and installation companies.

Bearing in mind the TCO as mentioned previously, it is always important to understand the levels and restrictions of your fire alarm system maintenance contract, regardless of who is supplying or installing. You need to be able to calculate upfront the expected costs of future maintenance to properly evaluate the TCO of the intended system.

Reference:

·        https://www.chrislewis.co.uk/blog/fire/open-v-closed-protocol-fire-systems

·        https://www.apollo-fire.co.uk/products/system-types/communication-protocol/

·        https://blazequel.com/blog/open-protocol-vs-closed-protocol-fire-alarms/#:~:text=Open%20protocol%20systems%20are%20generally,features%20and%20technology%20are%20preferred.

·        http://firealarmengineers.com/forum/showthread.php?tid=2665&pid=17208

·        https://www.hochikieurope.com/whitepapers/Open-Closed-Protocols.pdf