ISOLATOR INSTALLATION, INSPECTION AND SERVICE
Isolator module is used on the intelligent fire alarm
control panels to protect the system against wire-to-wire short circuits on the
analogue addressable loop wiring. Fire Projects designer know how and where to
use this isolators to get optimum performance. Some of OEM told short-circuit
isolator module which is designed to electrically separate and protect
vulnerable parts of the bus.
SOME DO’s AND DON’T’s
In the last twenty (or so) years, I’ve been privileged to
have been able to watch the tremendous advances in technology that continues to
inspire several manufacturers around the world to explore new developments in
electronic life safety systems. Unfortunately, each new advance
exposes some vulnerability that must also be addressed.
In this article, we’re going to discuss “isolators” and
more specifically, the correct wiring methods for the various types of circuits
you’re going to encounter, as well as the testing that must be performed, both
at the system’s commissioning/Verification and on an annual basis. We’re
going to focus on the changes currently adopted by the Canadian Standard for
Installation of Fire Alarm Systems (CAN/ULC-S524) as well as what’s “in the
pipe” in the way of amendments.
ISOLATOR TYPES AND TERMINOLOGY
What is an isolator, and how does it work?
Let’s begin by actually answering these two questions. An isolator is a
device that is designed to limit the extent a circuit is compromised by a
single “short” fault. In North America, there are four distinct
“families” of short circuit isolators. They are:
- Data Communication Loop (DCL) Isolators – some manufacturers call
them Signal Line Circuit (SLC) Isolators
- Power Buss Isolators
- Audio Buss Isolators
- Suite Signal Isolators
Most isolators are “dumb” devices comprising a
simple relay in a short sensing circuit on their “out” terminals. As long
as there is resistance on the circuit, they’re “happy”. When the
resistance drops to nothing (a short), they activate to preserve the loop
integrity on their “in” side. Some manufacturers have chosen to make
their isolators “smart” by employing their panel’s protocols to “communicate”
with each isolator. This has the advantage of being able to “group
bypass” an entire floor area from the common control if work is being performed
there, without affecting the operational status of the rest of the
system. You’ll usually find these isolators employed by companies that
are engaged in providing large scale networked type fire alarm systems (for the
obvious reason that it also makes testing easier).
APPLICABLE CODES AND STANDARDS
NBC 2015, VBBL 2019
The only time isolators are actually mentioned in
any Canadian Building Code is in conjunction with in-suite signalling
means. This is articulated in BCBC 2018 (as adopted from NBC 2015) in
Section 3.2.4.19 called Audibility of Alarm Signals and
reads in sentence (8):
“Audible signal
devices within a dwelling unit or a suite of residential or care occupancy
shall be connected to the fire alarm system:
a) in a manner such
that a single open circuit at one device will not impair the operation of other
audible signal devices on that same circuit that serve the other dwelling units
or suites of residential or care occupancy, or
b) on separate
signal circuits that are not connected to the devices in any other dwelling
unit, public corridor or suite of residential or care occupancy. (See Appendix
A.)”
CAN/ULC-S524-14
The Canadian Standard for Fire Alarm Installation
is where we will find reference to the installation of Data Communication Link
(DCL), network data, audio buss, and power buss fault isolators. We will
be using the abbreviations “DCL” “ND”, “AB” and “PB” for the purposes of this
article. It also deals with some specific installation requirements
governing the use of insuite signalling isolators.
We’ve provided links to diagrams at the bottom of
this page which detail both Class “A” interconnected field devices and a Class
“A” Riser interconnected to field devices in a Class “B” configuration as part
of this article. This is one area where the manufacturer’s installation
instructions also fall short and may even reference practices only
acceptable outside of Canada (i.e. NFPA
requirements). The essential difference between the drawings you’ll see
in the official amendment to the Standard and ours centres around one
additional isolator which we’re suggesting be added to the “return” side of the
loop to protect this part of the riser if you are employing
uni-directional isolators. In this instance, I’m of the opinion that
this qualifies as an improvement on the actual requirements of the Standard
(something that’s referred to as “good engineering practice”).
There are currently two versions of
CAN/ULC-S524-14. One includes the Amendments published in January of 2016
as a separate insert while the other will not have an amendment. Please
ensure your Standard includes the statement: “Including Amendment 1” on
the cover.
So, let’s begin with Clause 5.7.3:
“Where a data
communication link utilizing active field devices or supporting field devices
serves more than one National Building Code of Canada required fire alarm zone,
a fault within one National Building Code of Canada Required fire alarm zone
shall not prevent the normal operation of other input or output field devices
in another National Building Code of Canada required fire alarm zone, except as
noted in Clause 5.7.3.4.
Note: See
also Clause 4.3.1.8 and 4.3.1.9.”
5.7.3.4 states:
“Active field
devices or supporting field devices serving water flow devices, supervisory
devices on sprinkler systems, or duct type smoke detectors on HVAC systems that
are located within a National Building Code of Canada required fire alarm zone
but serve other National Building Code of Canada required fire alarm zones,
need not be separately fault isolated from each other or the National Buiilding
Code of Canada required fire alarm zone.”
5.7.3.5 states:
“A control unit or
transponder or its associated data communication link that serves more than one
floor area, shall be subject to the constraints of Clause 5.7.3.1.”
5.7.3.6 states:
“Data communication link style A with fault isolation modules, or data communication link style C with fault isolation modules, or an equivalent method shall be utilized to meet the requirements of Clauses 5.7.3.1, 5.7.3.4, and 5.7.3.5. (Refer to Figure 5).”
Inbuild Isolator Brand Like: ESSER, COOPER... etc
Base Isolator Brand Like: GST, Edwards... etc
Isolator as a Separate product Brand Like: Edwards, Notifier, Morley, GST, Apollo, Ravel... etc
Section 4.3 is entitled “ELECTRICAL SUPERVISION”.
4.3.1.8 states:
“Except as
permitted by Clause 4.3.1.10 or Clause 4.3.1.11, where a power buss circuit
serves more than one National Building Code of Canada required fire alarm zone,
a single fault (open circuit fault, short circuit fault or ground fault) shall
not prevent the normal operation of input or output field devices in more than
one National Building Code of Canada required fire alarm zone.
NOTE: Refer
to Appendix A (Informative) Explanatory Materials, Clause A4.3.1.8.”
4.3.1.9 states:
“Except as
permitted in Clause 4.3.1.10, where an audio buss serves more than one National
Building Code of Canada required fire alarm zone, a single fault (open circuit
fault, short circuit fault, or ground fault) shall not prevent teh normal
operation of input or output field devices in more than one National Building
Code of Canada required fire alarm zone.”
4.3.1.11 states:
“Where a power buss
serves supporting field devices which are located within a common National
Building Code of Canada required fire alarm zone but serve other National
Building Code of Canada required fire alarm zones, the power buss segment
serving these supporting devices is not required to comply with Clause
4.3.1.8.”
4.3.1.12 states:
“Class A circuit
with fault isolators installed in accordance with Subsection 10.2, Fault
Isolators, or an equivalent method, shall be utilized to meet the requirements
of Clauses 4.3.1.9 and 4.3.1.10.
NOTE: For
Data Communication Links, refer to Subsection 5.7.3, Field Device Data
Communication Link.”
Section 10.2 is entitled “FAULT ISOLATORS”
10.2.1.1 states:
“This Subsection
applies to the installation of fault isolation modules as required by
Subsection 5.7.3, Field Device Data Communication Link, for data communication
links between field devices. (Refer to Figures 33.1, 33.2, 33.3, and
33.4.)
Note: Where
available, data fault isolators should be located in a fire separated
electrical room.”
10.2.1.2 states:
“Data fault
isolators shall be utilized when entering and leaving each National Building
Code of Canada required fire alarm zone. See also Appendix A
(Informative) Explanatory Materials, Clause A4.3.1.8.”
10.2.1.3 states:
“Data fault
isolators required by Clause 10.2.1.2 are not required between field devices
located within the same floor area that are monitoring mechanical equipment
serving other floor areas.
NOTE: For
example, water flow devices on sprinkler systems or duct type smoke detectors
on HVAC systems serving other floor areas are considered part of the same area
specified in Clause 10.2.1.2 and need not be separately fault isolated from
other devices within that area.”
10.2.1.4 states:
“Except as noted in
Clause 10j.2.1.5, data fault isolators, shall be located in a separate
enclosure and installed so as to be visible and accessible at all times.”
10.2.1.5 states:
“Data fault
isolators that are integral to a field device shall be mounted in accordance
with the requirements of that field device.”
Note: Field
devices incorporating fault isolation modules complying with Clause 10.2.1.2 do
not require additional dedicated data fault isolators.”
10.2.1.6 states:
“Where a fire
separation is provided, data fault isolators required by Clause 10.2.1.2 shall
be installed on each side of that fire separation.”
10.2.1.7 states:
“Data fault
isolators installed on opposite sides of the same fire separation shall be
offset horizontally to a minimum of 400 mm, and not located within the same
stud space.”
10.2.1.8 states:
“Where no fire
separation is provided between each National Building Code of Canada required
fire alarm zone, a single fault isolation module shall be utilized when
isolating zones within the same floor area.
Note: This
Clause would be applicable to large horizontal buildings, e.g., warehouses,
shopping malls, factories, etc.”
10.2.1.9 states:
“Data fault
isolators serving a single field device in an exit or vertical service space
shall be installed on the floor area side.
Note: Fault isolation
modules are not required on the exit or vertical service space side. See
Figure 2.4”
10.2.1.10 states:
“Data fault
isolators shall have an identifying mark or label on the cover plate or field
device. The identifier shall be visible after installation. Where
field devices incorporating fault isolation modules are used to comply with
Clause 10.2.1.2, the first field device entering and the last field device
leaving each National Building Code of Canada required fire alarm zone shall be
marked.”